Boy baby lack who 's responsibility it will be right kidney?

Boy baby lack who 's responsibility it will be right kidney?
Lying-in woman claim whom school offer produce, examine report reveal out of question for several times Indict the hospital hospital and claim to check the rate of accuracy in Ultrasonography B to be impossible 100% in view of the above
Boy baby it born one years that if you can't check, find by kidney scarces right after more than like ( The right kidney is lacked) . The boy baby's mother Ms. Liu claims, successively went to the maternity child care center of Foshan to produce and examine 9 times during pregnancy by oneself, include Ultrasonography B 4 times to check, in the only three-dimensional color is exceeded, obtain the foetus' health very among them " L Perfect " . Regular Ultrasonography B is checked, appeared in antenatal ten days " L The right kidney has not seen that reveal " .
The intersection of Ms. and Mr. and Mrs. Liu think hospital it violates medical rules and medical care to be usually obligation, damage their bearing right and right of being in know, lodge a complaint against it, demand to compensate for nearly 30 ten thousand yuan.
" It would you please tell I,why foetus kidney scarces right it will be you let's find out like? " The specialized doctor points to Ultrasonography B and checks the photo in the report to ask the lying-in woman. This is a scene that happened in the court yesterday . Yesterday morning, the urban court of the deep meditation tried Foshan together publicly " Produce and examine the door " R Incident. Plaintiff Ms. Liu weigh she successively went to the maternity child care center of Foshan to produce and examine 9 times during pregnancy, include Ultrasonography B 4 times to check, in the only three-dimensional color is exceeded, obtain the foetus' health very among them " L Perfect " ,It suffer from by congenital heart disease after but child born detection and " Right kidney scarce like " . The hospital has responded on the lying-in woman's right of being in know and doubt of the parenting right, the case has not been pronounced in court.
Produce and examine and has not seen unusually many times
At the beginning of 2009, the Liu 's will all immerse in the happy atmosphere. The doctor tells them, after waiting for Ms. Liu to be pregnant for ten months, their family will add a lively baby newly.
During pregnancy, Ms. Liu is under the husband's company, successively women and children made for 9 times to produce examining in Foshan, including 4 Ultrasonography B inspection once.
In Ultrasonography B done on April 14 of 2009 is checked, reveal " L Influenced by body posture, a pair of kidney reveals that is unsatisfied with " . However, Ms. Liu says, after this Ultrasonography B was checked, the doctor has not advised her to carry on the further inspection immediately.
On June 15 of the same year, Ms. Liu chose relatively higher colored three-dimensional Ultrasonography B of the expenses in the regular woman produced and checked, but this report states clearly, stomach bubble, liver, a pair of kidney, bladder can reveal, have not seen that obviously unusual. Ms. Liu clears off in original doubt .
Question :
Check now unusually in antenatal ten days
August 15 of 2009, this is Ms. Liu before facing the plate, regular Ultrasonography B inspection of the second time counted backwards. " L The right kidney has not seen that reveal " ,See that checks these words in the report, a blank immediately of Ms. Liu's head.
Ms. Liu says, there was doctor's comfort at that time, shes, said that may just fail to reveal, but not really lacked a piece of kidney, even not a piece of kidney, will not bring the influence greatly on child's life in the future either. Ten day after produce, examine this time, act as little life come the world 25 day such as moon. Ms. Liu and others will be too gradually " L The right kidney has not seen that reveal " R Thing forget.
Check heart detection right scarce kidney such as
They which find one's own really son is right for kidney scarce like,after one year more than. " My child often falls ill, the local doctor advises me to go to the large hospital to check, see whether the body function especially heart respect is problematic. " L Ms. Liu claims, in November of 2010, they will be bringing son to Foshan city first the People's Hospital, having done a inspection of the whole body, this just finds, the child not merely suffers from inborn heart disease in surprise, and " R Right kidney scarce like " .
Tell them doctor,the child one heart disease issue actually and big,need doing by one of risks and big operations only, can fully recover . But lack one kidney for child, the intersection of women and Mr. and Mrs. Liu take to heart. They think, even the single kidney does not influence the health temporarily, but look like a regular bomb, may explode at any time . Especially the child should often take medicines now, there must be very great influence to his kidney.
The lying-in woman indicts the claim of hospital 30 ten thousand
Know behind the situation, Liu Ms. they try to coordinate with the hospital. If after they hoped the child if has really gone wrong, the hospital can bear half the treatment expenses, and the school would only like to return and produce and examine the expenses.
The end of last year, the intersection of Ms. and Mr. and Mrs. Liu think Foshan women and children it violates medical rules and medical care to be usually obligation, have damaged their bearing right and right of being in know, and lodge a complaint against women and children in Foshan. The amount of compensation that they required together is close to 30 ten thousand yuan, including attending to fee, special educational expenses, openheart surgery and treating the fee, kidney of heart and checking fee, spirit and damaging and conciliating gold regularly specially etc..
The urban court of the deep meditation held a hearing to the case publicly in the morning of yesterday. In yesterday's court's trial, the school determined to apply for the specialized agency to appraise, the case has not been pronounced in court .
Battle of the right of being in know
The single kidney is scarce to examine out?
In the court, Foshan respects of women and children point out, according to Guangdong Province>,Obstetrical department supersound check, can't find all the intersection of foetus and deformity, and the intersection of foetus and the intersection of form and kidney lack like whether antenatal Ultrasonography B check event that must be detected. When Ms. Liu checked before production, the school has already told her in written form, B it is impossible for the rate of accuracy exceeded and is checked to reach 100%.
Moreover after Ultrasonography B on August 15 of 2009 is checked, school tell the intersection of Ms. and the intersection of they and actual conditions of foetus Liu too, the problem of right of being in know of infringing them does not exist.
Ms. Liu responds and says, the school is in the inspection on June 15 of 2009 the same day, the tone that in order to be confirmed very much tells relatives a pair of kidney of the baby's is out of question. After another inspection after two months, just tell them " L The right kidney disappears to reveal " ,They have been already unable to change the set fact thoroughly at this moment.
Bear the battle of right
Could the lying-in woman stop gestation?
Ms. Liu claims, the school has infringed the right of their raising healthier, better educated children. " If that inspection told our child the situation which is short of kidney on June 15, we will choose not to need the child. "
The hospital says whether stop gestation having two kinds of situations, first, the doctor proposes, second, relatives require . If the doctor put forward, accord with the foetus and have serious hereditary disease or odd-shaped situation of causing death, look like the intersection of Ms. and these kind of situation of child Liu, doctors will not put forward voluntarily. School infringe the intersection of Ms. and couple Liu, bear right.
Relevant statement
Municipal Health Bureau : The hospital does not have unlawful practices
As to this incident, it is reported there is a special one in Foshan Municipal Health Bureau >.
Foshan Municipal Health Bureau is here >China takes a stand clearly, the women and children in Foshan do not have unlawful practice; Kidney of foetus' form lacks the project substantially as checked and must be tested out by antenatal Ultrasonography Bing; The women and children in Foshan have not performed duty of telling obligation and essential attention without existing.
|