Find the physical examination organization of tumour is sentenced to compensate behind man's physical examination is in good health 7 ten thousand

Find the physical examination organization of tumour is sentenced to compensate behind man's physical examination is in good health 7 ten thousand
Short short 3 months, forest Chinese (the name of melting) Calm life sinks to the bottom of valley in the twinkling of an eye . On June 23, 2007, he engraves renal Ultrasonography B that clinic Co., Ltd. does to reveal in organization Shanghai of physical examination remarkably and kindly " Have not seen that unusual " ,But 3 months later, he felt that went to the hospital to check in discomfort, found one 7.4 * 6.4cm long tumour of the left kidney unexpectedly.
After the left kidney is excised wholly, Lin Han does not think tumour can grow so fast during 3 months, that can find tumour while meaning physical examination . It is this, he informs the physical examination organization the court. Will it be August 31 this year, Xuhui court judgement kind to engrave clinic, compensate medical fee, wait for nearly or 7 ten thousand of expenses all kinds of.
" L Have not seen that unusual " R Kidney very unusual
Will it be June 23 2007, company that Han Lin belong to ask Shanghai engrave clinic, go on a physical examination for staff while being kind while being remarkable. While checking in renal Ultrasonography B, Lin Han's physical examination result is " L Have not seen that unusual " . I had never expected, short 3 months are less than, this " L Have not seen that unusual " R Kidney produce big problem.
Will it be September 17 2007, Han Lin appear hematuria accompany symptom of hyperpyrexia, reach the intersection of Yan Chai Hospital and clinic go on Ultrasonography B, CT,etc. check, found finally the possibility to suffer from kidney cancer was very great. 3 days later, he carried on left kidney cancer and radically treated the skill, finds in the operation, it is tumour long under the left kidney, big or small nearly have. . 4cm * 6.4cm. Though the operation goes on very smoothly, his left kidney is excised at this point.
This accident lets Lin HanShen attacked . He thinks, according to the present medical level, Ultrasonography B can be visited, found the diameter 1cm size tumour, but not found in the physical examination, make the kidney which he kept partly can only be excised wholly in time, have caused influence to his life. It is this, he will engrave the clinic to inform kindly that goes to the court.
Getting rid of the physical examination organization exist and leak and examine
As to the intersection of kidney and disease of Han Lin, kind to engrave clinic, it denies to be to leak, examine, think cancer this whether the intersection of he and one's own disease cause.
However, according to the qualification of East China University of Political Science Law judicial expertise centre, are developed into tumour greater in volume slowly by gene mutation cells, need to pass relatively long time, and Lin Han is from the physical examination to find tumour is fewer than 3 months, according to size at the time of the discovery, will not rise to such short time so big rapidly, it means " L Surveyor during clinic's physical examination of the hospital, exist objectively already tumour,it and achieve can visit Ultrasonography B resolution ratio at present already and size. "
Meanwhile, because engrave the clinic and has not carried on the routine and taken a picture and filed to Ultrasonography B kindly according to the routine, so it is difficult to get rid of existing and leaking and examining while engraving the course to Lin Han's physical examination of the clinic kindly.
In the course of physical examination, and a noteworthy detail. Han Lin, when the physical examination, include, it carries on doctors of Ultrasonography B for him to be here inside, in all 7 doctor to kind to engrave the intersection of clinic and the intersection of practising place and alteration yet. This method does not accord with the relevant regulation, in other words, this doctor had not carried on the qualification of physical examination for Lin Han at that time.
The physical examination centre can't put to the proof
Think court according to a present one level is it medical,can visit Ultrasonography B and kidney tumour diameter is for 0.2cm in size, because engrave the clinic and has not paid, taken a picture, filed kindly Ultrasonography B, so tumour size and position when can't confirm the forest Chinese physical examination, so engraving the clinic kindly should bear the responsible for can't put to the proofing. It employs and has not been engaged in already the doctor of alteration of practising place violating the relevant laws and regulations in medical activity, also will cause the medical dispute, as to this it should be stopped in medical treatment in the future moves about, standardize the medical behavior.
In that its one's own nephropathy of base excised on the basis of the forest Chinese kidney at the same time, smaller than tumour of 3cm the diameter though can consider excising partly, certain conditions are limited and not preferred healing solutions, so Lin Han requires that it is unreasonable to engrave the clinic to bear complete responsibility kindly. So, the court judges and engraves the clinic according to the proportion kindly that bears some responsibility, compensate for near all kinds of expenses 7 ten thousand yuan . Source : Moring Post

|